The Federal High Court in Abuja has ordered the extradition of a Nigerian, Temitope Seyi Omotade, to the United States to face trial over allegations of mail fraud, wire fraud, conspiracy and aggravated identity theft.


Justice Peter Lifu gave the order while delivering judgment in an extradition application filed by the Attorney-General of the Federation (AGF) on behalf of the United States government.


The judge held that the Federal Government had satisfied the legal requirements for Omotade's extradition to the United States District Court for the District of Minnesota, where he is expected to answer to a five-count indictment.


According to the prosecution, the indictment was filed on February 8, 2022, in case number 22-CR-24 SRN/HB. It contains three counts relating to alleged mail fraud, wire fraud and conspiracy under Sections 1341, 1343 and 1349 of Title 18 of the United States Code.


The offences carry maximum penalties of 30 years' imprisonment each, while the remaining two counts bordering on aggravated identity theft and aiding and abetting carry up to two years' imprisonment each, to run consecutively to any other sentence imposed.


Federal Government presents extradition request


In support of the application, the Attorney-General of the Federation relied on diplomatic communications from the US government, a sealed indictment and an arrest warrant issued by the Minnesota court.


The Federal Government maintained that the extradition request complied with the provisions of Nigeria's Extradition Act, adding that the offences were not political in nature.


It also informed the court that there were no pending criminal proceedings against Omotade in Nigeria over the offences in question and that necessary assurances concerning his treatment and trial in the United States had been obtained.


The extradition suit was marked FHC/ABJ/CS/494/2024.


Omotade denies allegations, challenges evidence


However, Omotade opposed the extradition request, urging the court to dismiss the application.


In his counter-affidavit, filed through his lawyer, he denied involvement in mail fraud, wire fraud, conspiracy and aggravated identity theft.


He also disputed allegations concerning his relationship with an individual identified as Roxanne Gilbert, maintaining that their dealings did not involve criminal activities or proceeds from fraudulent digital transactions.


Omotade further challenged the evidence presented by the Federal Government, arguing that it was insufficient to establish his alleged involvement in the offences.


He claimed that the supporting documents lacked blockchain analysis, financial transaction records, chat histories and video call evidence. He also suggested that third parties might have used his identity without his knowledge.


Court rejects health concerns


The respondent also raised concerns about his health, informing the court that he was receiving specialist medical attention for hepatic steatosis, commonly known as fatty liver, and elevated liver function levels.


He argued that extradition to the United States could expose him to serious health risks and would therefore be unjust and oppressive.


However, Justice Lifu rejected the argument, holding that the medical evidence presented did not sufficiently establish that extradition would expose him to grave and unavoidable medical consequences.


The judge noted that adequate medical facilities were available in the United States and that Omotade had failed to demonstrate that his medical condition constituted a legal barrier to extradition.


The court equally found no sufficient evidence that the extradition request was politically motivated or intended to persecute him on account of his race, religion, nationality or political opinions.


Justice Lifu emphasised that extradition proceedings are not intended to determine the guilt or innocence of a respondent but to establish whether the legal conditions for extradition have been satisfied.


He added that Omotade would have the opportunity to defend himself against the allegations through the appropriate judicial process in the United States.


Consequently, the court ordered his extradition to the United States District Court for the District of Minnesota to face trial over the five-count indictment.


The judge also dismissed his bail application, which was filed on September 16.


Omotade's extradition order does not amount to a conviction, as he remains presumed innocent until proven guilty before a competent court.