ABUJA — The Federal High Court in Abuja has removed Imo State Governor, Hope Uzodimma, as the All Progressives Congress (APC) candidate for Imo West Senatorial District in the 2027 general elections, declaring former governor Rochas Okorocha the lawful winner of the party's May 18, 2026, primary election.
The judgment, delivered on Thursday, October 29, by Justice Obiora Egwuatu, followed a legal challenge instituted by Okorocha against the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), the APC and Uzodimma over the recognition and publication of the governor's name as the party's senatorial candidate.
Why the Court Removed Uzodimma
A major reason behind the judgment was the court's finding that the documentary evidence presented to justify Uzodimma's emergence as the APC candidate contained serious inconsistencies and contradictions.
Justice Egwuatu reportedly questioned the authenticity of several documents tendered by the APC, observing that different party documents gave conflicting accounts of how the May 18 primary election was conducted.
According to the court, while one document indicated that Option A4 was adopted for the exercise, another account suggested that Uzodimma emerged through a consensus arrangement. A separate document, however, claimed that a direct primary election was conducted.
The judge considered these conflicting accounts significant, particularly because votes were reportedly allocated to aspirants despite the claim that the candidate had emerged through consensus.
The court consequently questioned the credibility of the documents submitted by the party, stating that their inconsistencies cast doubt on their authenticity and evidential value.
INEC's Election Report Became a Major Factor
Another significant factor was the report of INEC officials who monitored the APC primary election.
Okorocha had approached the court to determine whether INEC was legally bound to consider the reports submitted by its officials who monitored the exercise.
The former governor maintained that the monitoring records supported his claim that he won the primary but that the commission subsequently published Uzodimma's name as the winner.
In examining the evidence, Justice Egwuatu held that the documents obtained through the commission's monitoring process supported Okorocha's claim to victory.
The judge therefore faulted the recognition of Uzodimma as the party's candidate and declared that Okorocha was entitled to be recognised as the lawful winner of the primary.
What Okorocha Asked the Court to Determine
Okorocha instituted the suit, marked FHC/ABJ/CS/1854/2026, on August 13, 2026, challenging INEC's decision to publish Uzodimma's name as the APC candidate.
Among other reliefs, he asked the court to determine whether the commission acted lawfully by recognising Uzodimma despite the reports of its officials who monitored the May 18 primary.
He also sought an order setting aside the publication of Uzodimma's name and directing INEC to recognise and publish his name as the duly nominated candidate of the APC for Imo West.
In response, Uzodimma and the APC filed preliminary objections, arguing that the suit was statute-barred because it was instituted outside the 14-day period prescribed under Section 285(9) of the 1999 Constitution.
However, the court proceeded to determine the substantive dispute and granted Okorocha's principal requests.
APC, Uzodimma Disputed Okorocha's Claims
During the proceedings, Uzodimma and the APC maintained that the governor legitimately won the primary election.
The party's representatives argued that the election was conducted in substantial compliance with its constitution, guidelines and the Electoral Act 2026.
A member of the party's election committee, Lucky Ajokperiniovo, also maintained in a counter-affidavit that Uzodimma won the exercise with 230,464 votes, while Okorocha secured 1,098 votes.
INEC similarly opposed Okorocha's case, maintaining that its monitoring report indicated that Uzodimma scored the highest number of votes.
However, Justice Egwuatu found the documentary evidence supporting Okorocha's case more persuasive.
Court Orders INEC to Recognise Okorocha
Consequently, the court set aside INEC's publication of Uzodimma as the APC candidate for Imo West Senatorial District and ordered the commission to recognise and publish Okorocha's name.
The judge also restrained Uzodimma from presenting himself as the party's candidate for the January 16, 2027 senatorial election.
The APC was further directed to forward Okorocha's name to INEC as its duly nominated candidate.
Imo Government Rejects Judgment, Vows Appeal
Reacting to the judgment, the Imo State Government rejected the court's decision and announced plans to challenge it at the Court of Appeal.
The state Commissioner for Information, Declan Emelumba, criticised the ruling, arguing that Okorocha instituted the case 87 days after the primary election, beyond the constitutionally prescribed 14-day period.
The APC in Imo State has also questioned the judgment, raising concerns about its interpretation of constitutional provisions, judicial precedents and the evaluation of evidence.
The legal dispute now introduces another dimension to the political contest surrounding the APC's senatorial ticket for Imo West ahead of the 2027 general elections.
0 Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.
Leave a Comment