The Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) has urged the Federal Capital Territory High Court in Maitama, Abuja, to dismiss a no-case submission filed by former Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) Governor, Godwin Emefiele, in his ongoing trial over an alleged $6.23 million fraud.


The anti-graft agency argued that the evidence presented by the prosecution established a prima facie case requiring Emefiele to enter his defence.


The prosecution, led by the Director of Public Prosecutions of the Federation, Rotimi Oyedepo, a Senior Advocate of Nigeria (SAN), made the submission on Tuesday, October 20, 2026, before Justice Hamza Mu’azu.


The court heard arguments from both the prosecution and the defence before reserving its ruling. The date for the ruling is to be communicated to the parties through their lawyers.


EFCC Presents Evidence Against Emefiele


Emefiele is facing an amended 20-count charge bordering on alleged criminal breach of trust, forgery, abuse of office, conspiracy, obtaining money by false pretence and the alleged conferment of corrupt advantage in the award of CBN contracts.


One of the major allegations concerns the purported withdrawal of $6.23 million in cash from the CBN vault in Abuja for election observers ahead of the 2023 general elections.


According to the prosecution, the funds were released on the strength of letters purportedly issued by former President Muhammadu Buhari and former Secretary to the Government of the Federation, Boss Mustapha.


Oyedepo told the court that testimony from prosecution witnesses, including Mustapha and a forensic analyst, indicated that the documents used to facilitate the withdrawal were forged.


The prosecution also relied on testimony that the transaction triggered an automatic notification to Emefiele after the relevant account went into debit.


It argued that the former CBN governor’s alleged failure to act on the notification, alongside other evidence presented during the trial, raised questions about his responsibility for the funds.


The EFCC further alleged that part of the money was used to renovate one of Emefiele’s properties, while the remaining funds were reportedly recovered from an individual who received the cash.


These claims remain allegations before the court.


EFCC Challenges Defence Arguments


The prosecution maintained that a no-case submission is intended to determine whether sufficient evidence exists to require a defendant to enter a defence, rather than to establish guilt at that stage of the proceedings.


Oyedepo argued that the prosecution had presented sufficient evidence connecting Emefiele to the alleged offences.


On the contract-related charges, the EFCC alleged that procurement procedures were circumvented in the award of contracts to companies linked to the former CBN governor’s associates.


The prosecution contended that the alleged irregularities in the procurement process and evidence presented by its witnesses warranted a response from the defendant.


It also argued that the absence of a forensic examination of Emefiele’s signature would not automatically invalidate the forgery allegations.


Emefiele Insists He Has No Case to Answer


Emefiele’s lawyer, Matthew Burkaa, SAN, urged the court to uphold the no-case submission and discharge his client from the charges.


The defence argued that the prosecution had failed to establish the essential elements of the alleged offences, particularly the allegation that Emefiele conferred undue advantage on his wife and associates through CBN contracts.


Burkaa also questioned the evidence linking his client to the alleged forgery of documents used to withdraw the $6.23 million.


He told the court that former SGF Boss Mustapha had testified that his signature and that of the late President Buhari were forged on the relevant documents.


The defence further challenged the prosecution’s failure to conduct a forensic examination of Emefiele’s signature and argued that evidence of his approval of contracts did not, by itself, establish criminal wrongdoing.


Burkaa maintained that the prosecution had not sufficiently demonstrated that Emefiele manipulated the CBN’s tender process or personally benefited from the contracts in question.


Court Reserves Ruling


After hearing the submissions, Justice Mu’azu reserved his ruling on whether Emefiele should be called upon to enter his defence.


A no-case submission is an application by a defendant asking the court to terminate a criminal case at the close of the prosecution’s evidence on the grounds that the evidence presented is insufficient to justify requiring a defence.


The court’s forthcoming decision will determine whether the trial proceeds to the defence stage or whether the application succeeds.


Emefiele has not been convicted of the charges, and the allegations remain subject to judicial determination.