By PressPoint News |
Nigeria’s subnational finances are coming under renewed scrutiny as new fiscal data show that 26 states generated less Internally Generated Revenue (IGR) than they spent on personnel in 2025, underscoring the continuing dependence of most state governments on monthly allocations from the Federation Account.
The finding, contained in BudgIT’s 2026 assessment of state finances, presents a sobering picture of fiscal sustainability across the federation. Despite a substantial increase in government revenues following recent economic reforms, the majority of states are still unable to generate enough revenue from within their economies to independently meet their personnel obligations.
Of the 34 states for which comparable data were available, only Lagos, Enugu, Ogun, Delta, Kaduna, Kwara, Abia and Anambra recorded IGR above personnel expenditure during the period under review.
Akwa Ibom and Rivers were excluded from the comparison because of incomplete or unavailable data.
The remaining 26 states collectively generated approximately N1.16 trillion in IGR, against personnel expenditure of about N1.91 trillion — leaving a combined gap of roughly N747 billion.
The figures raise a fundamental question about the financial architecture of Nigeria’s states: if internally generated revenue cannot cover the public-sector wage bill in most states, how much fiscal room remains for infrastructure, education, healthcare and other development priorities?
FAAC BOOM, BUT FISCAL DEPENDENCE DEEPENS
The latest figures become even more significant when placed against the dramatic increase in federal transfers to state governments.
Aggregate allocations from the Federation Account rose from approximately N3.43 trillion in 2022 to N11.38 trillion in 2025, representing an increase of more than 230 per cent.
IGR also increased during the same period, rising from about N1.57 trillion to N4.15 trillion.
But there is a crucial difference between the two growth trajectories.
While states are collecting more revenue internally, federal transfers have grown at a faster pace. Consequently, FAAC's contribution to aggregate state revenue increased from approximately 68.7 per cent in 2022 to 73.3 per cent in 2025.
Conversely, the contribution of IGR declined from about 31.4 per cent to 26.7 per cent.
That creates one of the most striking features of Nigeria's current subnational fiscal landscape:
States are receiving more money, yet becoming relatively more dependent on the federation.
This distinction matters because revenue growth and fiscal independence are not necessarily the same thing.
LAGOS REMAINS THE OUTLIER
The national IGR picture continues to be heavily influenced by Lagos State.
Lagos generated approximately N1.85 trillion in IGR in 2025, accounting for about 44 per cent of the combined IGR of the states covered by the analysis.
Against personnel expenditure of approximately N333.67 billion, Lagos generated more than five times the amount required to cover its personnel costs.
The Lagos figure, however, also exposes the enormous disparity in revenue-generating capacity across Nigeria.
When Lagos is removed from the calculation, the remaining 33 states generated approximately N2.30 trillion in IGR, while their combined personnel expenditure stood at around N2.56 trillion.
The implication is significant: without Lagos, personnel costs among the other states collectively exceeded their IGR by approximately N254 billion.
Nigeria's subnational revenue story is therefore not simply one of poor performance across the board. It is a story of extreme concentration, with a handful of economically stronger states accounting for a disproportionate share of internally generated revenue.
OYO, YOBE, JIGAWA AND OTHERS FACE WIDER GAPS
The disparity is particularly pronounced in some states.
Oyo State generated approximately N102.52 billion in IGR, compared with personnel expenditure of about N170.04 billion, producing a gap of roughly N67.51 billion.
In Yobe State, the disparity was considerably wider. The state generated approximately N15.42 billion in IGR, while personnel expenditure reached about N76.34 billion.
Similarly, Jigawa recorded approximately N35.27 billion in IGR, against personnel expenditure of about N92.66 billion.
Other states with significant gaps included Ondo, Kogi, Bayelsa, Benue, Adamawa, Kano, Katsina, Borno, Ekiti, Osun, Plateau and Zamfara.
The pattern demonstrates that the challenge is not confined to one geopolitical zone. It cuts across the North, South-West, South-East and South-South.
OSUN: MORE REVENUE, BUT NOT ENOUGH TO CARRY THE WAGE BILL
Osun State also falls within the group of states where personnel expenditure exceeded internally generated revenue.
The state generated approximately N58.80 billion in IGR in 2025, while personnel expenditure stood at around N87.46 billion.
That represents a gap of approximately N28.66 billion between internally generated revenue and personnel costs.
The implication should not be misunderstood.
FAAC allocations are a legitimate source of government revenue, and there is no requirement that a state must pay its entire wage bill exclusively from IGR.
The concern is instead about fiscal resilience.
When a state's internally generated revenue is insufficient to cover its personnel costs, its ability to finance other recurrent and capital priorities becomes increasingly dependent on the stability of external revenue sources.
For states such as Osun, therefore, the challenge extends beyond simply improving tax collection. It involves expanding the productive base of the state economy and ensuring that economic activity translates into sustainable public revenue.
EIGHT STATES SHOW A DIFFERENT MODEL
While the overall picture is worrying, the performance of eight states provides evidence that a different fiscal trajectory is possible.
Lagos, Enugu, Ogun, Delta, Kaduna, Kwara, Abia and Anambra succeeded in generating more IGR than they spent on personnel in 2025.
Some states have also made significant progress over the period.
Abia, Delta, Enugu and Kwara moved from situations where IGR was below personnel expenditure in 2022 to positions where internally generated revenue exceeded personnel costs by 2025.
Such movement suggests that fiscal improvement is possible when revenue mobilisation, economic activity and expenditure management move in the same direction.
But the experience of Ebonyi and Jigawa, which moved in the opposite direction, equally demonstrates that progress is not guaranteed.
ANALYSIS: THE FAAC PARADOX
The latest figures expose what can best be described as Nigeria's FAAC paradox.
The Federation Account is providing states with significantly more money. Yet, for many states, that additional revenue has not translated into proportionately greater financial independence.
This is where the national conversation must move beyond the headline figures.
The problem is not that states receive FAAC allocations.
The problem is what happens after the money arrives.
If additional revenue is predominantly absorbed by salaries, overheads, administrative costs and other recurrent obligations, the immediate financial pressure may be reduced without addressing the underlying weakness of the state economy.
A state can therefore become richer in revenue while remaining poor in productive capacity.
That is the central warning contained in the latest figures.
THE REAL BATTLE IS NOT TAX COLLECTION
For years, the response to weak IGR has often been to demand higher taxes and more aggressive revenue collection.
But increasing taxes indefinitely is not a sustainable development strategy.
A stronger approach is to expand the economic base from which taxes are generated.
States need more businesses, more formal employment, stronger property markets, productive agriculture, industrial activity, technology enterprises, tourism, mining where appropriate, and investment in sectors capable of creating taxable economic value.
In simple terms:
Governments cannot tax an economy into prosperity. They must first create the conditions for the economy to grow.
A thriving business sector creates employment.
Employment creates income.
Income creates consumption.
Consumption generates transactions.
Transactions create taxable activity.
That is the economic chain that can produce sustainable IGR.
PERSONNEL COSTS ALSO REQUIRE SCRUTINY
There is another side to the equation.
Revenue cannot be considered in isolation from expenditure.
As states seek to increase their income, they must also examine whether their recurrent expenditure is sustainable.
Personnel expenditure is necessary. Teachers, healthcare workers, civil servants and other public employees are essential to the functioning of government.
But governments must continually ask whether their wage structures, administrative machinery and workforce expansion are aligned with the actual productive capacity of their economies.
The objective should not be indiscriminate downsizing.
Rather, states need more efficient public administration, better payroll systems, reduced leakages and stronger productivity.
Every naira committed to recurrent expenditure should ultimately support a government structure capable of delivering measurable public value.
WHAT THIS MEANS FOR NIGERIA'S FEDERALISM
The figures also revive the long-standing debate over fiscal federalism.
Nigeria's states possess different populations, natural resources, economic structures and revenue-generating capacities. Yet many remain heavily dependent on a common pool of federal resources.
That arrangement provides important fiscal equalisation, particularly for less economically developed states.
However, excessive dependence can weaken incentives for states to develop independent revenue bases.
The long-term objective should therefore be to create a federation where federal transfers support development rather than permanently substitute for local economic capacity.
That will require stronger local economies, more transparent public finances, better investment policies and a more productive relationship between government and the private sector.
FROM ALLOCATION TO PRODUCTION
The numbers point toward one unavoidable conclusion: Nigeria's states must begin measuring fiscal success differently.
The question should not simply be:
How much did we receive from FAAC?
It should also be:
How much economic value did we create with what we received?
A state that receives billions in federal allocations but remains unable to build a broad productive economy has not achieved genuine fiscal transformation.
Conversely, a state that uses public revenue to improve infrastructure, attract investors, expand businesses, formalise economic activity and broaden its tax base is building a stronger financial future.
This is why the next phase of Nigeria's economic reforms should place greater emphasis on state-level productivity and economic competitiveness.
THE PRESSPOINT VERDICT
The 2025 figures do not suggest that Nigeria's states are uniformly failing.
They reveal something more nuanced — and more important.
Some states are demonstrating that stronger IGR performance is achievable. Others remain heavily dependent on federal transfers to sustain their basic recurrent obligations.
The challenge for policymakers is therefore to replicate the conditions that have allowed stronger-performing states to expand their revenue base while preventing increased FAAC receipts from becoming a substitute for structural reform.
For states such as Osun, Oyo, Yobe and Jigawa, the path forward cannot simply be another cycle of waiting for the next FAAC allocation.
It must involve building stronger local economies, widening the formal tax base, attracting investment, improving revenue administration and controlling unnecessary recurrent expenditure.
Nigeria's states may have more money today.
But the real measure of reform will be whether they can eventually stand on stronger economic legs tomorrow.
PressPoint News Analysis
Source: BudgIT's 2026 analysis of state finances, with figures reported by The PUNCH.
0 Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.
Leave a Comment